Names You Can Count On

scales of justice icon

Experienced Attorneys in Jamestown, NY

When it comes to handling complicated and sensitive legal matters, put your faith in a trusted attorney. Since 1989, individuals and families across Jamestown, NY, have continued to put their faith in the expertise and resources at Bly, Sheffield, Bargar & Pillittieri. Our law office offers personalized solutions, constant support, and a background in a variety of practice areas, including personal injury, criminal defense, and estate planning. 

  • Auto Accidents
  • Personal Injury Claims
  • Bankruptcies
  • Divorce & Family Law
  • Real Estate
  • Criminal Defense
  • Wills, Estate, & Trusts
  • Business & Corporate Law 

attorney with paperwork

About Us

Our skilled team takes pride in exceeding the expectations of our clients with a multidisciplinary approach. Whether you need a divorce attorney or help with a criminal law matter, we have you covered. No matter the situation, when you call on Bly, Sheffield, Bargar & Pillittieri, you’re getting the top legal counsel in Chautauqua County.

pen icon

Peter A. Pillittieri

Peter Pillittieri was admitted to the New York State Bar in 1993. Mr. Pillittieri earned his Associate Degree from Jamestown Community College, his Bachelor of Arts Degree from the State University of New York at Buffalo in 1989, and his Juris Doctorate from the University of Akron in Akron, OH, in May 1992. His areas of practice consist of: criminal law, family/matrimonial law, general litigation, personal injury, mortgage foreclosure, and real estate.

He is a member of the New York State Bar Association and the Jamestown Bar Association and is also admitted to practice in the U.S. Federal Courts. He presently serves on the Board of Directors of the Chautauqua Blind Association, the Jamestown Area Midget Football Mediation Panel, and is a committee member of the Italian-American Charity Golf Tournament. Mr. Pillittieri also serves as an Attorney Coach for the New York State High School Mock Trial Program. Living in Jamestown, he is a member of Moonbrook Country Club and the St. James Roman Catholic Church.

pen icon

Mark L. Barger

Mark Bargar attended law school at the State University of New York at Buffalo and was admitted to the New York State Bar in 1987. Mr. Bargar’s practice is concentrated in the areas of residential and commercial real estate with an emphasis on representing mortgage lenders. Some lending institutions he represents include PNC Mortgage, IMC Mortgage, WMC Mortgage, Centex, Optimal Funding, Source One, Alliance, and Long Beach Mortgage. Mr. Bargar also counsels clients on business and corporate law, estate and succession planning, wills, trusts, and elder law issues. Mr. Bargar handles personal injury claims and has achieved substantial settlements for numerous clients in his career. He believes law should be practiced the "old-fashioned way," by taking a sincere and personal interest in a client’s case. Mr. Bargar also believes in the value of professional and community service. He is a member and past House of Delegate Representative to the New York State Bar Association. He is a member of the Jamestown Bar Association, Mount Moriah Lodge, and past President of the Town Club of Jamestown, NY. Mark resides in the lakeside community of Bemus Point, NY, with his wife and two daughters, where he enjoys golf, boating, and Lake Chautauqua.

Whether it’s a simple house closing or a complex commercial transaction, a will for an elderly parent or a serious personal injury case, you can always count on the best service from Mark Bargar and our entire staff of dedicated professionals at the law firm of Bly, Sheffield, Bargar & Pillittieri.

Get in Touch

Dedicated to providing comprehensive representation, Bly, Sheffield, Bargar & Pillittieri is prepared to tackle your serious legal needs. From personal injury and auto accidents to criminal defense and estate planning, our law firm offers quality advice and personal attention. Contact us today to schedule a consultation with a knowledgeable attorney. 

(716) 484-9151